Informing the Community | Civil Settlement Agreement and the 9/10 Pretrial Motion Hearing

What is the difference between the civil settlement and the criminal case?

There are two separate legal cases arising from the death of Freddie Gray, a criminal case and a potential civil suit. The criminal case, which can lead to criminal punishment like jail, is between the state of Maryland and the six officers. The civil suit would have been initiated by Freddie Gray’s family against the City.

After months of negotiation, the family agreed to settle all civil claims against the city (and the officers) for $6.4 million dollars. The settlement had to be approved by the Board of Estimates. As of this morning, the board approved the settlement. The sum will be paid to the family over the next two years. 

Does the civil settlement have any impact on the criminal trials?

No. The City agreeing to settle a potential civil suit is not an admission of guilt of any criminal wrongdoing. By settling with the family, the City accepted “civil liability” for the death of Freddie Gray, but this settlement cannot be used as proof of guilt against the officers in their individual criminal cases. There are numerous reasons parties decide to enter into settlement agreements. The City and the Gray family were able to avoid years of litigation by settling the claims.

What is the latest information regarding the criminal cases against the officers?

Because the civil and criminal processes are separate, the criminal trials against the six officers will continue to move forward as planned.

What happened at the September 10, 2015 pretrial hearing?

Judge Williams ruled that the Officers' trials will remain in Baltimore. 

If you have any questions, please contact us at info@baltimoreactionlegal.org. 

 

 

Informing the Community | Updates on the Officers' Pretrial Motion Hearings

Who is the judge?

Circuit Court Judge Barry Williams is a former city prosecutor and civil rights litigator. Judge Williams has been an associate judge in Baltimore Circuit Court since 2005. He led the court's criminal division from 2012 until January 2015 and chaired the Criminal Justice Coordinating Council for Baltimore from 2012 until 2014.

What has happened so far?

  • April 30, 2015: Mosby received the results of a police investigation of Gray's death.

  • May 1, 2015:  Mosby announced the charges against the officers.

  • May 8, 2015: Officers file motion to dismiss charges for prosecutorial misconduct and ask Mosby to recuse herself

  • May 21, 2015: A Baltimore  grand jury indicted the six police officers charged in the arrest of Freddie Gray. (Case moved from District Court to Circuit Court)

  • May 27, 2015: Officers file motion for removal out of Baltimore.

  • June, 26, 2015: Prosecutors filed motion for Goodson, White, Nero and Miller to be tried together.

  • July 10, 2015: Nero and Miller filed motion opposing prosecution’s intent to try them with Goodson and White.

  • August 17, 2015: Judge Williams quashed the subpoenas sought by Catherine Flynn to put Mosby, five other prosecutors, two investigators and an assistant medical examiner on the stand at the hearing scheduled for 9/2.  

  • September 2, 2015: Judge Williams decided against the officers’ request to have their charges dismissed and against the officers attempt to remove Mosby as their prosecutor.